Sarah Michelle Gellar wasn’t initially meant to return as slain beauty queen Helen Shivers in the new “I Know What You Did ...

"I'm Jenn Robinson, director and co-writer, and I don't know if you know who this is — she's a brand new actor, Sarah ...

Sarah Michelle Gellar, who played murdered pageant winner Helen Shivers in the 1997 teen horror flick “I Know What You Did ...

The actress and director Jennifer Kaytin Robinson showed up unannounced during multiple opening-weekend theatrical showings ...